The Science of Why Peer Perceptions Affect Us

December 12, 2022  |  Vince Kalt


Before I dive into how to influence peer perceptions, I think it’s important to spend a little time understanding why people think and behave the way they do. I’m no psychologist, but much of our time in the brand and positioning space looks to uncover truths that are fundamental to human and social behavior.

In this case, I want to look at the duality we see in higher ed: Why are universities bashing rankings one day, then promoting them the next?

We’re capable of believing that university rankings don’t mean anything in one context while also being drawn to university rankings in another context. This is due in large part to a phenomenon called contextual beliefs.

Validation and approval are fundamental human needs. We seek it socially as part of our overall psychological well-being. But evaluating how we’re perceived by others is difficult, so we’re drawn to tangible, easily measurable cues that communicate our value. Someone may tell us that we did a good job, but a cash tip gives a clear signal. The more money, the clearer the signal.

The same goes for social media likes. Some pundits will go on and on about not focusing on likes on social media, yet at the same time obsess over what kind of content garners the most engagement. Because we’re biased toward clear, easily measured indicators, we face a constant push and pull between our more rational minds that see the limited impact of these measures and our deeper emotional influences.

Jonathan Haidt uses the analogy of a rider and elephant. The elephant represents our unconscious emotional drivers behind our behavior and the rider is our rational thinking. In this analogy, appealing to the rider (rationally) has less of an impact than appealing to the elephant (emotional drivers) in terms of getting the rider and elephant to move together. In the context of university rankings, our understanding of the flaws of rankings is our rider speaking, but our draw toward rankings is the action of the elephant. The elephant is more powerful and can overtake our logical realization of the flaws of the rankings because the rankings represent a quick and easy-to-understand measure of our socially-recognized success that appeals to our emotional drivers.

To sum it up, there’s a reason we feel and behave in different ways. There is no unified “self” that generates internally consistent, and seamlessly coherent, beliefs devoid of conflict. Our psyche is wired to allow conflicting beliefs that are sometimes at odds. As such, we’re able to use university rankings to guide our behavior while at the same time believing that rankings don’t matter.

With a little more thorough understanding of why we think and act the way we do, we’re ready to head back into the research findings from BVK’s study “Influencing Peer Perceptions in Higher Education.” Up next, we’ll talk content, channels and timing!

If you’re intrigued and want to dig deep into the research findings, reach out. Email me at [email protected] and we can talk about getting your core team up to speed on the content, channels and strategies for advancing your university’s peer reputation.


is a Senior Vice President at BVK

Get updates from The Current

Which topics interest you?

Public Service
Travel & Tourism
Recreation & Lifestyle
Consumer & Retail
Financial Services
Thinking Big

More from The Current

May 25, 2023

From Experience to Transformation

What Travel Brands Need To Know During the last 25 years the U.S. has been largely driven by the Experience Economy. One wher...

March 28, 2023

Travel Insights: Consumer Mindsets & Travel Behavior

One quarter into 2023, current consumer mindsets represent a unique blend of trepidation and optimism. These broad-based stat...

January 4, 2023

Top Trends 2022-2023 – Now & Next

As society continues its volatility, industries are being shaped by people’s shifts in mindset and behavior. The top trends...

December 19, 2022

Influencing Peer Perceptions for Dummies

In my first post, I talked about the higher education phenomenon of bashing all things rankings while at the same time hangin...

December 12, 2022

The Science of Why Peer Perceptions Affect Us

Before I dive into how to influence peer perceptions, I think it’s important to spend a little time understanding why p...

December 5, 2022

Cats, Jammies & University Rankings

In August, we post back to school pics. In December, we post matching jammies pictures. And at every possible moment, we ogle...

November 29, 2022

Travel Insights: Gen Z and How They Are Changing Travel 

The New Culture Makers Rethink Travel In this month’s issue we focus on understanding how Gen Z’s cultural values are alr...

October 31, 2022

Travel Insights: Young Generations’ Priorities & Travel Solutions

It’s hard to believe that we are already welcoming Gen Z adults into the traveling marketplace. Many of us are just now com...

October 26, 2022

Does Your University Have a Brand?

Does Your University Have a Brand? If You Don’t Know, That’s a Problem American higher education pays too little attentio...